By Alex W Bealer
Illustrated by Kristina Rodanas
4.5 Stars
Historical
Adult
This
book also resides in my children's homeschooling library, again part
of the Sonlight history curriculum. It caught my attention mainly
because I have several good friends that are part Cherokee. Most
prominent would by Kitty Sutton who writes historical fiction related
to the Cherokee Nation. I've already reviewed the first two of her
books and will probably review the third book at some point as well.
Only
the Names Remain is short, 76 pages and the font is not small. There
are illustrations sprinkled through it. It is easily read in one
sitting. The prose for the literary amoung us, isn't anything to get
excited about, but it isn't boring. The subject and the content is
riveting enough.
I think
the book succeeds in its mission, which is to give a brief concise
history of the Cherokee and what happened to this still proud
American tribe. My only objection to the book is that it gives the
impression that the Cherokee Nation has been completely destroyed by
betrayal. The betrayal and cruelty is real but my Cherokee friends
still know they are Cherokee. I know they have many leaders who work
hard to make sure the next generation knows who they are and about
their history.
The
book begins in Georgia pointing out place names in what was once the
territory of the Cherokee Nation. It briefly mentions what is known
of their ancient history and then deals more with the period where
they adapted to the arrival of Europeans. It outlines their alliances
and enemies both native and European. From there it pinpoints the
events that lead up to their forced relocation. Finally it deals with
the infamous Trail of Tears itself where one in four died en route.
It is a sad and shameful event in American history and I think all
Americans should learn about it. I'm not American and never studied
American history in school except as it touched on Canadian history.
The fact that this was part of Sonlight curriculum, an American based
program, makes me think that maybe it is taught extensively. I do
wish it discussed where the Cherokee are today but it doesn't take
the reader significantly past the Trail of Tears.
As a
Canadian I don't believe I'm in any position to hate America for what
it did to the Cherokee. All they would have to ask is where the
Beothuk are today. We didn't march them anywhere. We just hunted them
to extinction.
I do
highly recommend the book for anyone.
No comments:
Post a Comment